Jack Tanner (1919-2006)

January 30, 2007 
/ Contributed By: Monica J. Benton

|

Jack Tanner

Jack Tanner was born in Tacoma, Washington in 1919.ย  His father, Ernie Tanner, was a respected local leader in the Tacoma local of the International Longshoremenโ€™s Union, an organization that Jack Tanner eventually joined when he worked on the cityโ€™s docks.ย  Before joining the union, however, Tanner was a star student-athlete at Stadium High School in Tacoma. Upon graduation he joined the U.S. Army in World War II and served in the Pacific in a segregated unit, an experience that provided this Pacific Northwest native his first view of racial discrimination as it was practiced in much of the United States. That view would influence Tannerโ€™s actions as a lawyer and later as a federal judge.

When he returned from World War II Tanner enrolled in the College of Puget Sound while working on the docks.ย  Upon graduation he enrolled in the University of Washington Law School and received a J.D. degree in 1955.ย  In the early 1950s Tanner was the only African American enrolled in the law school. Even after passing the bar Tanner kept his longshore job because the prospects for black attorneys in the Tacoma area in the 1950s were slim.

Jack Tanner joined the NAACP in law school and served as regional director of the civil rights organization from 1957 to 1965. While in that post he led protest marches in the early 1960s in Kennewick, Washington. Tannerโ€™s prominent leadership role in the Kennewick demonstrations and in the state NAACP eventually led to his appointment to the organizationโ€™s national board.ย  In 1963 Tanner was also called to the White House to advise President John F. Kennedy on race relations in the aftermath of the assassination of Mississippi Civil Rights leader Medgar Evers. Yet, Tanner did not view the problems of racial discrimination as unique to African Americans. Throughout his career as a crusading attorney he supported Native American activists in the Pacific Northwest who engaged in their own campaign against the disparity of treatment under treaties signed with our federal government.ย  Tanner was especially active in the fishing rights protests in the Olympia, Washington area in 1966.

Politically savvy, Tanner was active in the Washington State Democratic Party. In 1966 he became Washingtonโ€™s first black candidate for Governor when he entered the Democratic Primary. Although Tanner did not win the nomination he did gain the attention and eventually the confidence of important Democrats like Washingtonโ€™s Senators Warren Magnuson and Henry โ€œScoopโ€ Jackson. Tanner served as the Washington state campaign manager during Jacksonโ€™s unsuccessful bid for President in 1976, thus becoming one of the first African Americans in the nation to hold that post.

Donald McGavick, Jack Tannerโ€™s law partner, submitted Tannerโ€™s name in 1977 when an opening arose on the United States District Court. In 1978, after much public scrutiny but with crucial support from Magnuson and Jackson, Tanner became the first African American in the Pacific Northwest to be elevated to the federal bench.

Judge Tanner sat in both the Eastern and Western districts with a caseload three times the average assigned to other U.S. District Judges. His decisions drew controversy almost immediately. One ruling in 1980 declared that the state penitentiary at Walla Walla, Washington had violated the Eighth Amendment against cruel and unusual punishment. Another major decision in 1983 —ย  later characterized as the โ€œcomparable worthโ€ ruling —ย  established equal pay for women. Although eventually overturned by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Tannerโ€™s ruling received national attention and became a benchmark for expanding the economic rights of women. Judge Jack Tanner died at his home in Tacoma in 2006.

About the Author

Author Profile

Since March, 2008, Monica Jane Benton has served as a King County (Washington) Superior Court Judge. Born in Augsburg, Germany and later educated in the Taipei American School, Monica J. Benton gained an international perspective at an early age. As the adopted daughter of Captain B. J. Benton and his wife Velma Owens Benton, she became a naturalized U.S. citizen in the federal court located in Tacoma, Washington. In the same federal court twenty years later, she began her legal career as law clerk to the Honorable Jack E. Tanner, the districtโ€™s first African American judge. Providently, forty years after her naturalization, she was in 2000 appointed a U.S. Magistrate Judge in the same court and consequently became the first African-American woman to sit in that U.S. Court. Judge Benton held that judgeship until 2008.

Prior to her appointment to the United States District Court in 2000, Benton sat as a state-court judge for five years on the King County District Court. The appointment succeeded a decade of public service to the Criminal Division of the Office of the Prosecutor for King County. Bentonโ€™s area of expertise in child abuse prosecution led to a one year sabbatical serving as Senior Prosecutor for the American Prosecutors Research Institute, a think tank which provided both technical assistance and scholarly analysis.

Her current passion is the pursuit of American civil rights history. In her chambers she displays her collection of many important speeches, letters, and eyewitness biographies of those in the movement, including actual recordings taken from the Southern marches. Benton studied the narrative histories of the 1954 U.S. Supreme Court Justices as part of her participation in the 2004 re-enactment of Brown v. Board of Educationโ€™s oral argument before the Washington Supreme Court, sitting as the Warren Court. Additionally, she is a past-president of the Loren Miller Bar Association, an organization of African-American attorneys, and currently serves as editor of โ€œThe Petitioners,โ€ the barโ€™s annual newsletter. Formerly the barโ€™s historian, she coordinated the production of a collage of biographies of the barโ€™s founders and the city-wide exhibition of โ€œThe Rights of All,โ€ which celebrated the 200th anniversary of the signing of the U.S. Constitution.

Bentonโ€™s service to the community is seen in a myriad of associations including the Ninth Circuit Magistrate Judges Education Committee. Her commitment to judicial education began on the Research and Education subcommittees of the Washington State Minority and Justice Commission, while serving simultaneously as faculty member of the Washington Judicial College to develop diversity and access issues in state-wide judicial forums. Other areas of Bentonโ€™s civic interest include work for local and national charitable organizations as the YMCA and Links, Inc., and Youth Advocates.

CITE THIS ENTRY IN APA FORMAT:

Benton, M. (2007, January 30). Jack Tanner (1919-2006). BlackPast.org. https://www.blackpast.org/african-american-history/tanner-judge-jack-1919-2006/

Source of the Author's Information:

The Honorable Jack E. Tanner Papers, Washington State History Museum, Tacoma, Washington.

Further Reading